Athena is calling.
Athena is a toddler our three-year-old daughter Paulina met at the beach, which was serendipitous because we’d just come down the hill from visiting the Temple of Athena. The village over the mountain where Athena and her parents were living was scenic yet somehow charmless and hostile, like much of the rest of the country. They’d abruptly left a half paid off apartment in Moscow so her father wouldn’t be conscripted. Maybe there are no worse things than being sent to fight in Ukraine, but something had drawn us to this coast in a moment of total disillusionment and despair. It wasn’t supposed to be this way. It wasn’t supposed to happen to us.
We met at the University of Nevada in Reno. She was from Russia, and trying to stay past her high school exchange program. I was a refugee from a $1400 shared rental in Santa Barbara. Let’s just say we were compatible—I won’t belabor the point. Before Lena, I used to think that love was cerebral, all about liking the same books and music. But checking those boxes before you give it a test drive is a boring, navel gazing recipe for failure.
In the beginning we used to road trip a lot, mostly over to Tahoe or Santa Cruz on the weekends. We didn’t party. We didn’t drop in on old friends. We didn’t have any—it was just us. At one point we had to make it back from Truckee on 87 cents’ worth of gas purchased with the change in my ashtray, after fucking in a meadow along a creek, off a dirt road. Within three months she was pregnant and we got married by an Elvis impersonator at a drive-thru, with a handful of her exchange student friends.
We were 22 when we sealed the deal. She’d been pregnant for a month and we’d only known each other half a year. Our families were nonplussed. Both sides felt strongly that getting married instead of getting an abortion was stupid and naive. For a long time after we met, a part of me wondered whether she’d have married me if she already had citizenship, and a part of her wondered if I’d have married her if she hadn’t got pregnant. It was a tense but workable equilibrium.
Lena’s mom was a mail-order bride married to a trucker from Reno. He used to make a minor sideshow out of pretending to dress me down but Lena wasn’t really his daughter and he didn’t really give a shit about the situation. Conservatives love to indulge those little fake cowboy formalities. He had a pension from the Navy and Tatiana worked the perfume counter at Macy’s. They lived in a second-tier subdivision and drank quite a bit but never went too crazy with it.
Lena was living in the dorms when we met. Her real dad was in one of the big towns in the Urals, where he was in a long term romantic relationship with the wife of his paraplegic neighbor. He’d been a Red Army infantryman in Afghanistan and thought it was pretty cool that I’d done a deployment to Iraq. He used to send me books I couldn’t read, in Russian, about warfare and military history, with little hand-scrawled notes he insisted Lena translate for me, about exactly why he disagreed with each author and what each book’s redeeming qualities were. It was cute and I always knew I liked him.
Within seven years of marriage we had a couple more kids, three total. We never used protection and never had a planned pregnancy. Making ends meet was stressful, and for a few years I worked menial jobs while she finished her engineering degree. Then I took the family down to Vegas for a few years to do law school, which was rough, especially since Lena was working full-time. We were always in debt and our fights were explosive, in a little two-bedroom balsa wood apartment. But we stuck it out.
By the time we’d been together a decade I’d been a lawyer for a year and we’d only had one vacation alone together—two nights at Harrah’s in South Tahoe. Our summer trips with the kids were all to crappy water parks and campgrounds, never anything nice or too relaxing. The best we’d ever managed was a week in Santa Cruz, but she hadn’t seen her dad in twelve years and it was time to meet him, no matter the cost. Only problem was that war had just broken out in Ukraine. On a Russian passport you couldn’t really enter Europe or the U.S., and Americans couldn’t get a visa for Russia either. That left Turkey, so we set a calendar date for six months out and blew our savings on airfare and hotel reservations.
Turkey is like the crappy water park of countries—you have to fly right over Nice and Florence and Salamanca to get there, but we didn’t care. We were excited—until we found out Lena was pregnant again. We were in our mid-thirties by this time, just barely getting financial ground beneath us. Neither of us was thrilled by the news. For some odd reason Lena’s nausea was intense and wouldn’t let up even after she’d been pregnant for six weeks. Her birthday was three days before we were supposed to leave town. By the time we started getting ready to leave, she was thirteen weeks, just showing but not obviously pregnant. That was when we got the results of a screening which indicated to a near certainty that the baby had Down syndrome. When the nurse first called with the test results, I asked the baby’s gender, since that was part of what the screening was supposed to show. The nurse stammered at first, as if humanizing the child by conceding it had a gender went against protocol, but she told us it was a girl.
At first I brushed off the news—there had to be a mistake. But we scrambled to get an appointment, parked the kids with babushka, and went to get a placenta sample taken for a diagnosis. I thought we were opposed to abortion, so it seemed pointless to follow up on the screening with a diagnostic test. Why would we do a diagnostic test if we weren’t going to have an abortion? But Lena was hysterical and under the circumstances I wasn’t going to start arguing with her.
In guise of ethnic art, the OBGYN clinic had these slapdash pueblo style archangels painted on wooden boards all over the waiting room walls. I sat beside Lena in the darkened exam room while they extracted a cell sample and we left the clinic in tears. It was a Catholic hospital, and on our way out I noticed a plaque on the outside of the building with St. Jerome’s prayer. I tried to take hope but I also knew that if I stopped to dote on this curio Lena would smell bullshit and it would only make things worse. And she’d have been right, because in my heart of hearts, when I said the prayer to myself in the car it wasn’t for the baby to be born alive, it was for the placenta sample result to show the baby wasn’t retarded. We drove home, sucked it up, and hid our agony from the kids while we packed, knowing the dreadful news would come in Istanbul and in that dark hour we would have to bury our grief again and keep going. If we’d been resolute in our beliefs there’d have been no need for this charade, but you never stop burying things you take to the grave.
The first thing you do when you find out you’re pregnant with a lemon is start googling like crazy. That’s what Lena did, at least, and it quickly became clear to her that if we had this baby, we would be lifelong hostages to the insurance industry and the hospital system, and that not even St. Jerome could bring the tab within reasonable proportion. Down syndrome is more than an intellectual disability. Contrary to what you see in the media, the vast majority of these kids are physically disabled, some severely. Many have significant behavioral issues—violent outbursts, sexual impulsivity. As adults their aging parents can’t care for them, and eventually they’re parked in miserable facilities. Even if the siblings ever visit, no one wants to take them home. We also read that having a retarded child breaks marriages at an overwhelming rate. And Lena said that it was clear to her from perusing message boards and blogs about the topic that many of the mothers standing up for these children are well-to-do, cognitively dissonant stay-at-home moms, whereas we were both working full time with three kids, and I was $120K in debt for law school. I couldn’t see any of this as an argument for taking our daughter’s life—but I couldn’t not see it that way, either.
The other thing you do when you get a Down syndrome diagnosis is vacillate maniacally. At first, when it was clear to me that Lena was leaning heavily toward getting an abortion, I rationalized this and my thoughts became ice cold to an extent I hadn’t thought possible, like it was my lips moving but another person’s voice coming out, and expressing these rationalizations to Lena made her recoil and agonize badly. The night before our flight, our eldest son Max had a nightmare that Lena killed herself and he found her body in the twilight, wearing a bathrobe, hanging from the ceiling beam in the bedroom with her toes pointing down at the Sesame Street chair from Paulina’s kiddie table, kicked-over and laying sideways on the carpet.
Once onboard the flight from Dallas, packed into coach and taxiing on the runway, I did a 180, perhaps as a way of imploring God not to abort me in that airplane. Clarity cut through in the tremors of takeoff: what we were premeditating was the murder of an innocent child, our child, just because she was different. There was no way around it. There still isn’t, and I knew I would be a Cain on the Earth forever. Worse than Cain—at least Abel was a grown man. Hell, Abel was annoying, but our daughter never offended anyone. What angel would ever protect us again? I tried to imagine what my late grandparents would think about the situation, and was troubled to reflect that despite their professed religiosity, all four of them would’ve favored practicality, and that their sadness in the situation would’ve been for me and not for the baby.
Trying to shepherd a family of five through the throngs and public restrooms and airport security and passport control all the way from Reno to Istanbul was a slog, and Lena was doing it three months pregnant with a baby we were planning to murder. We were tense. There was something cute and endearing about the Turks, however, almost from the moment we encountered them. They’re an absolutely charmless people, but practical, and from the time we got in line to board Turkish Airlines in Dallas, it was a very family-friendly atmosphere. It was an overnight flight, but the kids were well behaved, even Paulina, who was fussy at that age. One of the reasons Lena was so settled on aborting was because she was working from home and Paulina was very rambunctious.
We had an Airbnb on the European side. The hills were steep and the alleys were narrow, but while the neighborhood wasn’t clean, it wasn’t seedy or menacing either. Our apartment was cramped but it had a terrific view of the Bosphorus, within easy walking distance of Goleta, Istiklal, Besiktas, and the Quay. Our upper story balcony was directly facing the Crimean Memorial Church, a dignified and understated moss-and-ivy smothered 19th century stone Anglican affair built to commemorate Britain’s Crimean War fallen. For the entire week we spent in Istanbul, every day, five times a day, massive loudspeakers from the mosques inundated the city with the azan, and every morning the bells from the church across from our apartment rang out in a cacophony. Lena and I fell silent when these rich sounds intruded. God was watching and we were in flagrante delicto. And not in a good way.
It was late when we arrived, but we had to stay up because Lena’s dad wouldn’t get there until after midnight. I found takeout and walked it back to the apartment up the eight stories of narrow, creaky wooden stairs in our five-hundred year old building. Ivan arrived around 1am and his meeting the kids for the first time was very touching in spite of the language barrier. He was a short, skinny bald man, formerly blond, with piercing blue eyes and rough hands and a nose flattened from fistfights ancient and legendary, wearing Belorussian leather shoes that the soles were trying to escape from, and he cried when saw Paulina. We decided we would walk up to Istiklal in the morning and find him a pair of New Balance.
After a few more days in the city—Maiden Tower, the Blue Mosque—we tracked down a rental car and headed south, to Assos, where we had reservations for five nights in a little coastal resort. It was a nice place with manicured lawns and clean bungalows and a pool and kids’ play area. We were the only foreigners but all the other guests were families, upper middle class Turks mostly from Ankara. When we first got there the kids ran off to the pool with their grandpa. Lena and I found ourselves alone in the room and had a moment of abandon after spending six hours in a hot car. I caught her taking off her make-up and started fucking her over the bathroom countertop, but when she saw her pregnant body in the mirror she burst into tears. I finished anyway.
The place where we were staying had this garden patio style restaurant where we ate every night, right across from the beach. There was no church or mosque anywhere around, but there was soft jazz and classic rock playing over little loudspeakers mounted on the side of the building, and our first night there when we sat down to dinner they were playing Eric Clapton’s Tears in Heaven. My heart turned to cinderblock in my chest.
The next morning at the beach, Ivan started in about military topics. I knew enough Russian to get by with him, and at some point I started trying to burnish myself with this stupid story about a philosophical conversation I’d had in the Army. It was late at night on patrol outside Mosul and one of my buddies started expounding an amoral theory of war where he tried to justify civilian casualties, even children. I had of course taken the opposite view, which was the point of telling this story to Ivan. He took a drag off his cigarette, squinted into the sun and said, “A real soldier would never hurt a child.”
After we came home we all caught COVID. Lena recovered quickly but the day of the abortion I was running a 102 degree fever. The night before, I sat up late. The kids had been running back and forth to the yard earlier in the day with the screen door standing open, and as I sat staring blankly at the walls a grasshopper popped up out of the corner behind a bookshelf. Normally I would kill a cockroach, but grasshoppers are not so repulsive, and before I’d even thought about it I had the creature trapped in a Solo cup and opened the sliding glass door to let it out. The utter incongruousness of this act of compassion with the abortion we had planned for the morning overwhelmed me and I began trembling like I never have in my life. My sleep that night was strangely deep and anesthetic.
It was the summer solstice. The waiting room was large and empty, except for a very young girl sitting beside a grey haired man, apparently her father, who when I glanced at him shot back an icy look right in my eyes that said, who the fuck are you to judge me?
They put us together in a dark, freezing exam room. We decided to give the baby a name, and wept unconsolably. Then the moment arrived and the nurse came to take Lena to the operating room. The way I understood it, they were going to pump her full of fentanyl and vacuum the baby out of her. It sounded gruesome. Almost stumbling, still febrile, I walked in a daze through the freezing corridor, into the waiting room and past reception. There was an armed security guard in the front. My car had been sitting in the sun about an hour and it was warm inside. I fell asleep with the windows up and woke up an hour later to the news that I was the proud father of a healthy baby girl. I saw Lena sitting up in a hospital bed nursing our newborn and I felt drawn to them like a vision of light. Then I realized that I’d only been dreaming. The buoyancy of the dissipating image turned to a sense of distance and abandonment. I knew that I had directly felt my daughter’s soul and the shame and grief I now felt were bottomless, all the more so because I knew that I would bury it and continue like nothing happened. The whole thing was a concession, a capitulation, to everything elderly and mean that we’d been resisting when we found out we were pregnant for the first time all those years ago, and decided to get married.
For two weeks we were completely broken and non-functioning. The haze of grief and remorse was intoxicating, like adrenaline from shock, and for some strange reason we were extremely horny and fooled around a lot, even though we couldn’t actually fuck. But eventually, it wore off, and as we made our way back to work and routine a real dark night of depression and guilt came down on us. It’s been about a year now and I guess you could say we’ve been back to normal for half that time. But when I go outside at night and gaze up at the canopy of heaven I feel nothing. The stars are cold, atheistic and indifferent to me now, and I to them. Athena’s mom is still sending Lena recorded messages on WhatsApp, of Athena babbling to Paulina in Russian. Paulina has a plastic bracelet Athena gave her, and she keeps pointing to it and telling everybody she got it from “my Athena.”